281.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
21 >
Issue: 2
Eli Diamond
Substance and Relation in Aristotle’s Political Philosophy:
A Reply to Sean Kirkland
abstract |
view |
rights & permissions
This paper explores Sean Kirkland’s thesis that relation is the fundamental concept in Aristotelian political philosophy. While substance is prior to relation in Aristotle’s metaphysics, Kirkland argues that since the human exists only in the context of a city which is defined by the essential diversity of views on the human good, relation precedes substantial unity in politics. I argue that the priority of the substantial unity of the city should not be seen to threaten the importance of political relations. Already in his theoretical ontology, Aristotle sees relation as absolutely essential and integral to the identity and existence of any mortal individual. Because of the essentially dynamic and relational activity of any mortal substance, the city as political substance must include and preserve deep diversity and difference within itself. The priority of the substantial over the relational, which makes possible the constitutive power of relations in the life of substances, is as operative in politics as it is in metaphysics.
|
|
|
282.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
21 >
Issue: 2
Christopher Cohoon
Friendship and the Divine Wish:
Re-Reading Nicomachean Ethics 1159a5–12
abstract |
view |
rights & permissions
According to Aristotle’s reply to what I call the divine wish aporia (NE VIII.7 1159a5–12), perfect friendship entails wishing many great goods for one’s friend, but precludes wishing that one’s friend become a god—“the greatest of goods”—for the realization of this wish would destroy the friendship. Counter both to this reply and to the slim body of existing commentary, which appeals to the external criterion of equalizable reciprocation, I demonstrate how the perspective internal to the virtuous activity of perfect friendship affords properly Aristotelian grounds for retaining the divine wish as its constitutive limit. While the practicable scope of perfect friendship remains circumscribed within human limits, its characteristic wishing at once reaches beyond the human—and the friendship.
|
|
|
283.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
21 >
Issue: 2
Travis Holloway
How to Perform a Democracy:
A Genealogy of Bare Voices
abstract |
view |
rights & permissions
This paper explores a type of poetry, music, and theater that is said to be responsible for the birth of participatory democracy. While Aristotle and Nietzsche briefly mention a similar genealogy of democracy in their work, Book III of Plato’s Laws archives a remarkable history of how participatory democracy emerged in Athens’s theater. After connecting Plato's account to a participatory style of music and poetry that is associated initially with the term polyphōnia, I consider a line of philosophical commentary on this type of music from Plato to Rousseau to Derrida. For these philosophers, I claim, polyphōnia disrupts the political hierarchy of those with and those with bare voices and encourages equal participation. If the phenomenon of polyphōnia is indeed behind Plato’s historical account of democracy in the Laws, then it may tell us how democracy was first performed in the theater and how it was initially critiqued by philosophers.
|
|
|
284.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
21 >
Issue: 2
Aaron Shenkman
Multus Homo Es:
Desire, Identity, and Conquest in Catullus’s Carmina
abstract |
view |
rights & permissions
Quietly nestled in Catullus’s early love poems, there are two grammatical ambiguities that, although provoking heated grammatical discussion in the commentary tradition, have been completely overlooked by more literary and theoretical writers. In these brief moments, the distinction between man and women, lover and loved, vir and irrumatus, becomes problematized, to say the least. Moving through and unpacking the form of Roman masculinity that is so prevalent in Catullus’s poetry, this paper looks to ultimately understand the place of these ambiguities in our collection of Catullus’ work. In so doing, it explores and uncovers a fundamental engagement with the gender-political situation in Rome, and ultimately attempts to show how Catullus not only bests his male counterparts through his poetry, but also deconstructs the very idea of what it is to be a vir in the first place.
|
|
|
285.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
21 >
Issue: 2
Sean D. Kirkland
On the Ontological Primacy of Relationality in Aristotle’s Politics and the “Birth” of the Political Animal
abstract |
view |
rights & permissions
In this paper, I begin with the most basic tenet in Aristotelian metaphysics, namely that ousia or ‘substance’ is ontologically prior to the nine other categories of being, including the pros ti, the condition of being literally ‘toward something’ or what is sometimes called 'relation' or ‘relationality.’ Aristotle repeats this frequently throughout his works and it is, I take it, manifest. However, in the Politics, so I argue here, Aristotle’s dialectical study of common appearances leads him to describe ‘human being’ in a way that runs contrary to this. That is, insofar as the human being is the zoon politikon or ‘political animal,’ it seems to be constituted as the being it is precisely by way of its relatedness to other human beings in the polis. I then try to determine the moment of ‘birth’ for this essentially relational being, and find that it may not be the emergence of the human from the womb, but rather, at least according to this interpretation of the Politics, the moment when we enter into the logos together with others in posing, discussing, debating, and re-posing the abidingly open question of the human Good.
|
|
|
286.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
John Ellis
Δύναμις and Being:
Heidegger on Plato’s Sophist 247d8–e4
|
|
|
287.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
Françoise Dastur
Heidegger and Derrida:
On Play and Difference
|
|
|
288.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
Joel Shapiro
Originary Pain:
Animal Life Beyond the Pleasure Principle in Kant’s Anthropology
|
|
|
289.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
Kelly Oliver
The Gestation of the Other in Phenomenology
|
|
|
290.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
Charles E. Scott
On Originating and Presenting Another Time
|
|
|
291.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
3 >
Issue: 1/2
Daniel W. Conway
Writing in Blood:
On the Prejudices of Genealogy
|
|
|
292.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 1
Dennis King Keenan
Skepticism and the Blinking Light of Revelation
|
|
|
293.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 1
Frank Schalow
The Third Critique and a New Nomenclature of Difference
|
|
|
294.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 1
Richard A. Cohen
Justice and the State in the Thought of Levinas and Spinoza
|
|
|
295.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 1
Paul Moyaert
Lacan on Neighborly Love:
The Relation to the Thing in the Other Who Is My Neighbor
|
|
|
296.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 2
Jean Grondin
Hermeneutics in Being and Time
|
|
|
297.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 2
Rudi Visker
The Untouchable:
Merleau-Ponty’s Last Subject
|
|
|
298.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
4 >
Issue: 2
Natalie Depraz
Scientific Metaphysics and Transcendental Empiricism
|
|
|
299.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
5 >
Issue: 1/2
Béatrice Han
Beyond Metaphysics and Subjectivity:
Music and Stimmung
|
|
|
300.
|
Epoché: A Journal for the History of Philosophy:
Volume >
5 >
Issue: 1/2
James McLachlan
The Theological Character of Sartre’s Atheology in Being and Nothingness
|
|
|